|
great ocean report – May 2010
It is fair to say that the Australian property market has had an amazing run over the past 12 months the strength of which defied most economists and established industry commentators.
If we use the Melbourne median house price as a guide we can see that it has risen 29.5% from the end of the March quarter in 2009 ($405000) to the end of the March quarter 2010 ($524500). The peak of activity being in the December quarter of 2009.
Everything is easy in hindsight to review but this property market was actually not that difficult to predict. The increase in dollar amounts of the median house price is always difficult to predict but the increase in activity is not. This is simply because the property market always comes back to one simple rule of economics – supply and demand and the sentiment (fear and greed) attached
to it.
One very interesting phenomenon that is occurring in the Australian property market is that the cycles are getting shorter. If we look back to after the late 1980’s property boom when the recession hit around 1990 the property market stayed flat for about 7 years. Then we had a strong period from 1997 to 2003 (values in our coastal market roughly tripled in this period) which ended in November 2003. The next buoyant period in the property market was in 2007 (3 years between peaks). Then the GFC loomed and the stock market plummeted in 2008. Interest rates dropped and the property market started looking very attractive resulting in a very positive 2009 (2 years between peaks). And now we find ourselves in 2010.
Let’s now look back at these cycles and see how by applying the rules of supply and demand and the sentiment attached to this we can predict what a property market will do. Let’s first agree that everyone does what everyone else does. As much as we all like to think of ourselves as individuals most of us follow the herd. The stock market is the most fluid and volatile example of this.
I will go back to 2003 for this illustration. In a buoyant market generally supply increases because property owners take the opportunity to sell their property at the increased price being offered by increased demand from buyers. After a strong six year run in November 2003 two things happened at once that reduced demand. Interest rates rose to a level that took residential property investors out of the market. The returns being offered were just not attractive enough anymore with increased finance costs. Basically negative gearing lost its luster. Also the government changed the auction rules to outlaw dummy bidding. This meant there was a lot of single bidder or no bidder auctions. This was a very public display of sentiment that weighed heavily on the property market. This in turn reduced supply in 2004-2005 because people tend not to sell when they do not have to. The property market was steady rather than terrible but it was the booming stock market that had investor’s attention (sentiment).
At the start of 2006 the Australian property market started a new run. Interest rates had hardly moved since December 2003 the strong stock market was providing both positive sentiment and profits. Financial advisers were advising their clients to diversify by taking advantage of the flat property market with these profits and this started increased demand for property. Given that everyone does what everyone else does the property market started to pick up speed and despite rising interest rates saw a stellar run through to the end of 2007. Increased demand saw increased supply as prices rose. Then the GFC hit very early in 2008 with the Australian Stock market falling approximately 2000 points over the next six months. This severely dinted sentiment and the whole world put whatever they were doing on hold which affected both supply and demand. The property market in the USA was in freefall and the Australian media was doing its best to scare the hell out of everyone (remember Steve Keen!).
By 2009 it was evident that Australia had a separate set of principles in play to the rest of the world. The government was visible in creating economic stimulus and the Reserve Bank had drastically cut back interest rates. Unemployment was not dramatically rising and most Australians found themselves with more disposable income than they had expected. Positive sentiment was increasing and with a flat property market cheap interest rates more cash and no allure from the stock market property looked attractive.
There were also some other factors that underwrote the Australian property market and increased demand from strong immigration was one of them. Approximately 1800 new people per week were (and still are) arriving in Melbourne and they need somewhere to live. Add to this the government relaxing the law on the type of property that temporary visa holders could buy adding an extra layer of buyers especially from China (some of the most spectacular individual results in 2009 and 2010 can be directly attributed to these buyers). As 2009 wore on and with this strong base in place everyone decided to join in and demand increased. Early in 2009 supply was tight but the volumes increased as the year wore on as property owners as we have already mentioned are more likely to sell in a buoyant market.
So here we are in 2010. The Melbourne metropolitan market has seen an amazing run but the gloss has come off in the past few weeks from its highs of the December quarter last year. It had to really because the rate of appreciation was just not sustainable. Our observation is that it will probably return to more sustainable levels. Interest rates have risen to temper the appetite of some sectors of the market and the stock market is providing some negative sentiment at present which also makes people nervous. Overall we still have a general under supply of housing to service the demand for our growing population and this will keep us in good stead for some time to come. We think the peaks and troughs will continue to be short and shallow because of this overall lack of supply.
How does this all affect coastal property specifically? As most of the buyers come from Melbourne positive or negative sentiment directly affects the coastal property market particularly so because they are usually discretionary buys. We have very limited supply (only about 8000 properties in the towns of Anglesea Aireys Inlet and Lorne all together) with little expansion possible. Yet we have a capital city of 4 million people rising to 5 million over the next 20 years 90 minutes away with no traffic lights between us. We think we can safely assume demand is assured but like any property market at levels subject to the ebb and flow of the sentiment of the day. At present we have the lowest stock levels we have ever seen after very consistent demand over the past year. |